Stop Tracking Clicks

The Big Idea: Top of Mind / Attention

Marketing’s job isn’t to rack up clicks, it’s to win attention. Attention creates awareness, awareness creates demand, and demand shows up later as branded search, direct visits, leads, and sales.

Deep, “surgical” targeting looks smart on a slide, but you pay a hidden tax for that precision. In today’s privacy-limited world, broad often beats narrow on both cost and future demand.

How We Got Stuck on Clicks

Dashboards made clicks look like truth. Last-click reports hand all the credit to the final tap before a purchase, which is convenient for platforms and misleading for you.

Analogy: If a shopper puts a Coca-Cola on the counter and the cashier rings it up, should the cashier get credit for the sale? Of course not. The brand was built by years of reach, the display in the aisle, the memory in the buyer’s head. Last-click attribution is like giving the checkout person all the credit for that Coke—because they “touched it last.” It’s tidy, but wrong.

Attention → Awareness → Action: The Real Funnel

Pre-digital brands (think Yellow Pages if you’re old enough to remember that – if not, Google it) grew on reach and frequency. That physics hasn’t changed. The more qualified people who see you enough times, the more you lodge in memory. When a need appears, the brand they remember gets the first swing. We’re kind of back to where it started, which I think is cool.

• Attention: Your message is seen (impressions).
• Awareness: People now recognize/recall you (top-of-mind).
• Action: When it’s time to buy, they search for you, visit you, or click you.

Expect a lag: impressions lift this week → clicks lift days later → sales lift weeks later. Plan budgets with that delay in mind.

Why Deep Targeting is a Tax Now

• Privacy shifts (cookies, ATT, walled gardens) broke “perfect” tracking and shrunk match rates.
• Layering audiences raises your CPMs and shrinks your reach. You pay more to talk to fewer people.
• Broad lets the algorithm find tomorrow’s buyers you can’t pre-define—and you buy that reach cheaper.

Bottom line: Narrow can look efficient this week, but broad builds demand you’ll capture for months.

What to Track Instead: Keep a Simple Daily Sheet

Clicks and platform “conversions” are diagnostics, not decision fuel. The operating metric is daily impressions by channel and creative.

Make one spreadsheet with these columns:

• Date
• Channel (Meta, YouTube, Search, CTV, Retail Media, etc.)
• Campaign / Creative (short name)
• Impressions (daily)
• Spend (daily)
• Clicks (optional diagnostic)
• Leads / Sales (daily totals or orders)
• Notes (PR hit, email drop, promo, anomaly)

For organic video, log the daily delta (today’s total views minus yesterday’s total). Build a pivot that shows Total Daily Impressions across all channels and a simple line chart.

How to Read the Signals

• Impressions up → a healthy pipeline of attention.
• Clicks up (with a lag) → consideration is following.
• Sales up (with a longer lag) → awareness is converting.

Look for impression spikes that consistently precede lifts in revenue. Those are your builders. Fund them.

How to Make Decisions with It

• Budget to the builders: Shift 10–20% weekly toward campaigns/creatives that create sustained impression momentum.
• Keep a test lane: 10–15% for new audiences/creatives so you keep finding tomorrow’s builders.
• Use clicks to diagnose, not to steer. If impressions are flat, don’t chase CPI; fix creative/reach.

Proving It on a Budget (Incrementality Without a Lab)

• Geo holdout mini-test: Concentrate spend in City A for 2–3 weeks. Compare orders vs. City B over the following 4–12 weeks. Note spillover and seasonality in your sheet.
• Micro-experiments: You’re already turning ads on/off and swapping creatives. Tag those dates in the Notes column and watch the downstream effects.

Channels That Fill the Funnel Now

• Meta (broad): Let the algo hunt widely. Win with creative variety and frequency, judge by impression momentum.
• YouTube: Treat as modern TV. Use hooks in the first 3–5 seconds; mix UGC-style and polished assets.
• CTV / Retail Media: Great for reach and recency. Reporting is siloed—your sheet is the unifier.
• Search: Protect branded terms and run capture, but don’t confuse capture with creation.

Tool Reality Check (GA4, Pixels, GTM)

Install pixels, set up GTM, and wire GA4 correctly—then keep perspective:

• GA4 is Google-centric. It sees some things well, others partially.
• Platform “conversions” are biased. They’re hints, not truth.
• Your daily impression log is your compass. It spans all channels and respects the lag.

Step-by-Step Playbook

1. Build the sheet and backfill 60–90 days if you can.
2. Log daily impressions from every paid/organic channel. For organic video, log the daily delta.
3. Create a line chart of Total Daily Impressions. Optionally overlay clicks and sales as separate lines.
4. Identify builders: campaigns/creatives whose impression surges precede revenue lifts.
5. Reallocate 10–20% of budget weekly toward builders. Keep 10–15% for tests.
6. Run one geo holdout per quarter to sanity-check incrementality.
7. Document anomalies (PR, emails, promos) so outliers don’t mislead you.

Objections You’ll Hear and How to Respond…

• “But my ROAS dashboard—” Great for troubleshooting, not for strategy. ROAS is capture; impressions create demand.
• “My audience is niche.” Perfect—broad reach still finds them cheaper, and frequency builds memory in a small market.
• “I need wins this week.” Keep a small performance lane for capture, but fund brand so you’re not renting clicks forever.

Suggested Visuals

• Figure: Line chart—Daily Impressions (primary), Clicks and Sales overlays showing natural lag.
• Figure: “Audience Layering Tax”—Base CPM vs. CPM with multiple layered filters.
• Sidebar: DIY Geo Holdout (3-week setup + 4–12 week observation).

Conclusion

Stop worshiping the last click. Start managing your attention supply. Build brand awareness instead. When you buy awareness efficiently, track it daily, and stick with it through the lag, you build a brand that wins before the search even happens.

Remember that marketing aims to win attention for brand awareness and future demand, emphasizing broad reach over deep targeting in a privacy-limited digital landscape to build sustained impression momentum and drive sales. Don’t get off into the weeds.

Marketing’s focus should be on winning attention, not just racking up clicks. Prioritize building brand awareness through broad reach over deep targeting in today’s privacy-limited digital landscape. By tracking daily impressions and investing in sustained impression momentum, you can drive future demand and sales effectively.

---

Glossary of Terms Used in this Article

Impressions

The number of times your ad or content was shown. It’s an attention proxy, not a guarantee that someone noticed.

Reach

The number of unique people who saw your message at least once.

Frequency

How many times, on average, each person saw your message (Impressions ÷ Reach).

Top-of-Mind Awareness (TOMA)

Being the brand people think of first when a need appears. Built by reach and frequency over time.

ATT

Apple’s iOS 14.5+ privacy framework that requires apps to ask permission to track users across apps/sites via the IDFA.

IDFA

Apple’s device advertising ID. With ATT, most users opt out, limiting cross-app tracking.

GA4

Google’s analytics platform. Good at measuring Google traffic; other channels can be partial or modeled.

GTM

Tag management tool that installs and controls pixels/scripts without constant code pushes.

Pixel

A small tracking script from an ad platform used to measure events (views, clicks, purchases) on your site.

Last-Click Attribution

Giving 100% credit to the final click before a purchase. Like crediting the cashier for selling the Coca-Cola—the brand work happened earlier.

Incrementality

Sales you wouldn’t have gotten without the marketing. The lift caused by your campaigns.

Geo Holdout Test

Run heavier spend in City A and hold back in City B for a few weeks, then compare sales to estimate true lift.

Walled Garden

Platforms (e.g., Meta, Amazon) that keep their data inside, making cross-platform attribution difficult.

CPM

Cost per 1,000 impressions. A core pricing unit for awareness buys.

ROAS

Revenue ÷ ad spend. Useful for capture channels, but can under-value long-term brand building.

CTV

TV content delivered via internet-connected devices (Roku, Apple TV, smart TVs). Great for reach.

📄 Download a PDF of This Article